Effective treatment of knee replacement: A Synthesis of Findings from 23 Studies
- Home
- Effective treatment of knee replacement
This analysis is based on research papers included in PubMed, but medical research is constantly evolving and may not fully reflect the latest findings. There may also be biases towards certain research areas.
This information is not medical advice and is not a substitute for diagnosis or treatment by a physician. If you have concerns about "Effective treatment of knee replacement: A Synthesis of Findings from 23 Studies", please consult your doctor.
For NLM copyright information, please see Link to NLM Copyright Page
PubMed data is obtained via Hugging Face Datasets: Link to DatasetPlease check the disclaimer.
Major research findings
There are various approaches used for rehabilitation after knee replacement surgery. One study, 5 , suggests that ergometer cycling can have a positive impact on health-related quality of life and patient satisfaction. Another study, 6 , compared unicompartmental knee replacement (UKA) with total knee arthroplasty (TKA), and indicated that UKA could achieve similar clinical effects as TKA. However, the study also pointed out that UKA has a higher conversion rate. On the other hand, 22 , a systematic review and meta-analysis comparing UKA and TKA, concluded that UKA is as effective as TKA for simple medial knee OA. These studies provide valuable insights for developing rehabilitation strategies after knee replacement surgery.
Treatment Summary
5 uses ergometer cycling as a treatment. 6 compares UKA and TKA as treatments. 10 uses early Tuina treatment. 21 compares TKA and UKA as treatments. 18 uses prehabilitation as a treatment.
Benefits and Risks
Benefit Summary
Knee replacement surgery is an effective treatment that can improve severe knee pain and dysfunction, enhancing quality of life. Specifically, 6 suggests that UKA could potentially achieve clinical effects similar to TKA, with the advantage of faster postoperative recovery. Additionally, 5 indicates that ergometer cycling may have a positive impact on quality of life and patient satisfaction.
Risk Summary
Like any surgery, knee replacement carries risks such as infection, blood clots, and bleeding. 6 points out that UKA has a higher conversion rate compared to TKA. Furthermore, 3 highlights the potential for patellar fracture after knee replacement, which could lead to postoperative pain and dysfunction.
Comparison between studies
Commonalities between studies
Many studies indicate that knee replacement is an effective treatment for severe knee pain and dysfunction, improving quality of life. Moreover, numerous studies emphasize the importance of postoperative rehabilitation.
Differences between studies
Each study differs in terms of patient population, treatment methods, and evaluation methods, leading to varying results. For instance, 5 evaluates the effectiveness of ergometer cycling, while other studies do not utilize this treatment. Similarly, 6 compares UKA with TKA, while other studies do not perform this comparison.
Consistency and contradictions in the results
Several studies conclude that knee replacement is an effective treatment method. However, there are contradictions, such as 6 , which suggests that UKA has a higher conversion rate compared to TKA. Additionally, 2 indicates that patellar resurfacing does not significantly impact knee function after knee replacement. These contradictions highlight the need for further research.
Cautions for real-life application
Knee replacement surgery is an effective treatment for severe knee pain and dysfunction, but obtaining adequate information before surgery is crucial. It's essential to understand the potential risks, especially the higher conversion rate associated with UKA compared to TKA, as outlined in 6 . Postoperative rehabilitation is crucial for knee function recovery. 5 suggests that ergometer cycling might positively impact quality of life and patient satisfaction. However, it's vital to undergo appropriate rehabilitation based on your individual condition and physician's instructions.
Limitations of current research
Current studies have limitations such as a small number of participants, short follow-up periods, and differences in treatment methods and evaluation procedures. Furthermore, 20 points out that patients' self-management capabilities can influence postoperative outcomes. However, this factor is not considered in many studies.
Future research directions
Future research should involve a larger number of participants and longer follow-up periods. Additionally, as suggested by 7 , interventions to enhance patients' self-management abilities, such as postoperative exercise therapy and psychotherapy, should be explored. Moreover, a more detailed analysis of the cost-effectiveness of TKA and UKA, as outlined in 19 , is necessary.
Conclusion
Knee replacement surgery is an effective treatment for severe knee pain and dysfunction. However, gaining sufficient information before surgery is crucial. Postoperative rehabilitation is essential for knee function recovery. Further research is required to thoroughly understand the safety and efficacy of knee replacement surgery.
Treatment List
Ergometer cycling, UKA, TKA, Tuina treatment, prehabilitation
Benefit Keywords
Risk Keywords
Article Type
Author: BarrackR L, WolfeM W, WaldmanD A, MilicicM, BertotA J, MyersL
Language : English
Author: CampbellD G, DuncanW W, AshworthM, MintzA, StirlingJ, WakefieldL, StevensonT M
Language : English
Author: ChalidisByron E, TsiridisEleftherios, TragasAdamantios A, StavrouZois, GiannoudisPeter V
Language : English
Author: HanssonUlrik, Toksvig-LarsenSören, RydLeif, AspenbergPer
Language : English
Author: LiebsThoralf R, HerzbergWolfgang, RütherWolfgang, HaastersJörg, RussliesMartin, HassenpflugJoachim
Language : English
Author: SunPeng-Fei, JiaYu-Hua
Language : English
Author: RosalMilagros C, AyersDavid, LiWenjun, OatisCarol, BorgAmy, ZhengHua, FranklinPatricia
Language : English
Author: OdumenyaMichelle, McGuinnessKatie, AchtenJuul, ParsonsNick, SpaldingTim, CostaMatthew
Language : English
Author: SkouSoren T, RoosEwa M, LaursenMogens B, RathleffMichael S, Arendt-NielsenLars, SimonsenOle H, RasmussenSten
Language : English
Author: WangNian-hong, YanJun-tao, SunWu-quan, HuYong-shan, XiaJun, WeiLi-cheng, JiaJie, OuyangGui-lin, HeYong, GuoYan-ming, XuJie
Language : Chinese
Author: PillingR W D, MoulderE, AllgarV, MessnerJ, SunZ, MohsenA
Language : English
Author: HuberErika O, de BieRob A, RoosEwa M, Bischoff-FerrariHeike A
Language : English
Total or Partial Knee Arthroplasty Trial - TOPKAT: study protocol for a randomised controlled trial.
Author: BeardDavid, PriceAndrew, CookJonathan, FitzpatrickRay, CarrAndrew, CampbellMarion, DollHelen, CampbellHelen, ArdenNigel, CooperCushla, DaviesLoretta, MurrayDavid
Language : English
Author: SkouS T, RoosE M, SimonsenO, LaursenM B, RathleffM S, Arendt-NielsenL, RasmussenS
Language : English
Author: VolpinAndrea, KiniS G, MeuffelsD E
Language : English
Author: ChristiansenMeredith B, ThomaLouise M, MasterHiral, SchmittLaura A, PohligRyan, WhiteDaniel K
Language : English
Author: EvansJonathan T, WalkerRobert W, EvansJonathan P, BlomAshley W, SayersAdrian, WhitehouseMichael R
Language : English
Author: JahicDzenan, OmerovicDjemil, TanovicAdnana Talic, DzankovicFuad, CamparaMerita Tiric
Language : English
Author: BeardDavid J, DaviesLoretta J, CookJonathan A, MacLennanGraeme, PriceAndrew, KentSeamus, HudsonJemma, CarrAndrew, LealJose, CampbellHelen, FitzpatrickRay, ArdenNigel, MurrayDavid, CampbellMarion K,
Language : English
Author: TimmersThomas, JanssenLoes, van der WeegenWalter, DasDirk, MarijnissenWillem-Jan, HanninkGerjon, van der ZwaardBabette C, PlatAdriaan, ThomassenBregje, SwenJan-Willem, KoolRudolf B, Lambers HeerspinkFrederik Okke
Language : English
Author: BeardDavid J, DaviesLoretta J, CookJonathan A, MacLennanGraeme, PriceAndrew, KentSeamus, HudsonJemma, CarrAndrew, LealJose, CampbellHelen, FitzpatrickRay, ArdenNigel, MurrayDavid, CampbellMarion K
Language : English
Author: DengMeichao, HuYang, ZhangZhongzu, ZhangHongjun, QuYiming, ShaoGaohai
Language : English
Author: JenkinsCathy, LoweCatherine Minns, BarkerKaren L
Language : English
This site uses cookies. Visit our privacy policy page or click the link in any footer for more information and to change your preferences.