Effective treatment of miscarriage: A Synthesis of Findings from 32 Studies
- Home
- Effective treatment of miscarriage
This analysis is based on research papers included in PubMed, but medical research is constantly evolving and may not fully reflect the latest findings. There may also be biases towards certain research areas.
This information is not medical advice and is not a substitute for diagnosis or treatment by a physician. If you have concerns about "Effective treatment of miscarriage: A Synthesis of Findings from 32 Studies", please consult your doctor.
For NLM copyright information, please see Link to NLM Copyright Page
PubMed data is obtained via Hugging Face Datasets: Link to DatasetPlease check the disclaimer.
Major Research Findings
A study published in 9 found that the method of managing early miscarriage (expectant management, medical management, or surgical management) does not affect subsequent pregnancy rates. About 80% of women who experienced a miscarriage gave birth within five years. The study concluded that women do not need to worry about long-term fertility concerns when making decisions about their miscarriage management.
In cases of incomplete evacuation of the uterus after misoprostol treatment for miscarriage, a study in 21 found that curettage leads to a higher chance of complete evacuation compared to expectant management. However, expectant management is successful in at least 76% of women. This finding suggests that curettage is a more effective option for complete evacuation, but expectant management is a safe and viable alternative that can avoid curettage for many women.
A study comparing micronized progesterone (MP) and dydrogesterone (DYD) for threatened miscarriage, published in , found no statistically significant differences in bleeding severity or subsequent miscarriage rates between the two treatment groups. However, fewer patients treated with DYD reported drowsiness and dizziness compared to MP. The finding of significantly higher miscarriage rates in women with low progesterone levels, regardless of treatment type, highlights the importance of considering progesterone levels when counseling and making predictions about pregnancy outcomes.
Treatment Summary
The study published in 9 showed that the method of managing early miscarriage (expectant management, medical management, or surgical management) does not affect subsequent pregnancy rates. The study published in 21 demonstrated that curettage is more effective for complete evacuation of the uterus after misoprostol treatment than expectant management, but expectant management is a safe and viable alternative. The study in found no significant differences in bleeding severity or miscarriage rates between micronized progesterone (MP) and dydrogesterone (DYD) treatment, but dydrogesterone was associated with fewer reports of drowsiness and dizziness.
Benefits and Risks
Benefit Summary
The method of managing early miscarriage does not affect subsequent pregnancy rates 9 .
Expectant management is a safe and viable option that can avoid curettage for many women 21 .
Risk Summary
Curettage is more effective for complete evacuation, but it can carry a higher risk of complications compared to expectant management 21 .
Dydrogesterone may be associated with fewer side effects, such as drowsiness and dizziness, compared to micronized progesterone .
Comparison Between Studies
Similarities
The studies agree that the method of managing early miscarriage does not affect subsequent pregnancy rates. They also concur that expectant management is a safe and viable alternative to curettage for many women.
Differences
The studies differ in their findings regarding the effectiveness of curettage compared to expectant management for complete evacuation of the uterus after misoprostol treatment. They also vary in their findings about the side effect profiles of different types of progesterone medications.
Consistency and Contradictions in Findings
The findings about the lack of impact of miscarriage management methods on subsequent pregnancy rates are consistent across studies. However, there are contradictions regarding the effectiveness of curettage versus expectant management for incomplete evacuation of the uterus. Additionally, further research is needed to fully understand the differences in side effect profiles of different progesterone medications.
Application to Real-Life Situations: Points to Consider
When choosing a method of managing early miscarriage, it is crucial to consider individual circumstances and preferences. Women should discuss their options with their healthcare provider and fully understand the risks and benefits of each approach. When using progesterone medications, it's important to be aware of the potential side effects.
Limitations of Current Research
Many studies on the long-term impact of miscarriage on pregnancy rates have a follow-up period of only five years. Longer-term follow-up studies are needed to fully understand the long-term impact of miscarriage. There are often concerns about the reliability of findings in studies comparing curettage and expectant management, as they tend to have smaller sample sizes. Furthermore, research comparing the side effect profiles of different progesterone medications may have limited generalizability due to the small range of medications and administration methods studied.
Future Research Directions
Future research should involve longer-term follow-up studies to assess the long-term impact of miscarriage on pregnancy rates. Larger, more robust studies are needed to compare curettage and expectant management for incomplete evacuation of the uterus. Additionally, future research should expand the range of progesterone medications and administration methods studied to enhance the generalizability of findings.
Conclusion
Numerous studies have shown that the method of managing early miscarriage does not affect subsequent pregnancy rates. However, further research is needed to determine the most effective approach for complete evacuation of the uterus after misoprostol treatment. It is important to remember that choosing a method of managing early miscarriage should be a collaborative decision between women and their healthcare providers, considering individual circumstances, preferences, and potential risks and benefits.
List of Treatments
Expectant Management, Medical Management (Misoprostol, Progesterone), Surgical Management (Curettage), Micronized Progesterone, Dydrogesterone
Benefit Keywords
Risk Keywords
Article Type
Author: JohnsonN, PriestnallM, MarsayT, BallardP, WattersJ
Language : English
Author: ClevinL, MunkT, HansenT R
Language : Danish
Author: Wieringa-de WaardMargreet, VosJeroen, BonselGouke J, BindelsPatrick J E, AnkumWillem M
Language : English
Author: Wieringa-de WaardMargreet, BindelsPatrick J E, VosJeroen, BonselGouke J, StalmeierPeep F M, AnkumWillem M
Language : English
Author: NandaK, PeloggiaA, GrimesD, LopezL, NandaG
Language : English
Author: NeilsonJ P, HickeyM, VazquezJ
Language : English
Author: WahabiH A, Abed AlthagafiN F, ElawadM
Language : English
Author: FawzyMuhammad, ShokeirTarek, El-TatongyMohamed, WardaOsama, El-RefaieyAbdel-Aziz A, MosbahAlaa
Language : English
Author: SmithLindsay F P, EwingsPaul D, QuinlanCatherine
Language : English
Author: NeilsonJames P, GyteGillian Ml, HickeyMartha, VazquezJuan C, DouLixia
Language : English
Author: WahabiHayfaa A, Abed AlthagafiNuha F, ElawadMamoun, Al ZeidanRasmieh A
Language : English
Author: WahabiHayfaa A, FayedAmel A, EsmaeilSamia A, Al ZeidanRasmieh A
Language : English
Author: TorreAntoine, HuchonCyrille, BussieresLaurence, MachevinElise, CamusErick, FauconnierArnaud
Language : English
Author: NandaKavita, LopezLaureen M, GrimesDavid A, PeloggiaAlessandra, NandaGeeta
Language : English
Author: KongGrace Wing Shan, LokIngrid Hung, YiuAlice Ka Wah, HuiAnnie Shuk Yi, LaiBeatrice Pui Yee, ChungTony Kwok Hung
Language : English
Author: NeilsonJames P, GyteGillian M L, HickeyMartha, VazquezJuan C, DouLixia
Language : English
Author: VerschoorMarianne A C, LemmersMarike, BossuytPatrick M, GraziosiGiuseppe C M, HajeniusPetra J, HendriksDave J, van HooffMarcel A H, van MeursHannah S, OpmeerBrent C, van TulderMaurits W, BouwmaLiesanne, CatshoekRuby, GeominiPeggy, KlinkertEllen R, LangenveldJosje, NieboerTheodoor E, van der PloegJ Marinus, RadderCeline M, SpinderTaeke, van der VoetLucy F, MolBen Willem J, HuirneJudith A F, AnkumWillem M
Language : English
Author: MekinianArsène, CohenJonathan, Alijotas-ReigJaume, CarbillonLionel, Nicaise-RolandPascale, KayemGilles, DaraïEmile, FainOlivier, BornesMarie
Language : English
Author: ChanDiana Man Ka, CheungKa Wang, YungSofie Shuk Fei, LeeVivian Chi Yan, LiRaymond Hang Wun, NgErnest Hung Yu
Language : English
Author: ShaabanOmar M, AbbasAhmed M, ZahranKamal M, FathallaMohamed M, AnanMohamed A, SalmanSafwat A
Language : English
Author: LemmersM, VerschoorM A C, Oude RengerinkK, NaaktgeborenC, OpmeerB C, BossuytP M, HuirneJ A F, JanssenC A H, RadderC, KlinkertE R, LangenveldJ, CatshoekR, Van der VoetL, SiemensF, GeominiP, Van HooffM H, Van der PloegJ M, CoppusS F P J, AnkumW M, MolB W J,
Language : English
Author: BettsDebra, SmithCaroline A, DahlenHannah G
Language : English
Author: SacconeGabriele, SchoenCorina, FranasiakJason M, ScottRichard T, BerghellaVincenzo
Language : English
Author: CavalcanteMarcelo Borges, SarnoManoel, Araujo JúniorEdward, Da Silva CostaFabricio, BariniRicardo
Language : English
Author: KimCaron, BarnardSharmani, NeilsonJames P, HickeyMartha, VazquezJuan C, DouLixia
Language : English
Author: SiewJia Yun S, AllenJohn C, HuiCelene Y Y, KuChee Wai, MalhotraRahul, ØstbyeTruls, TanThiam Chye
Language : English
Author: WahabiHayfaa A, FayedAmel A, EsmaeilSamia A, BahkaliKhawater Hassan
Language : English
Author: WangXiao-Xue, LuoQing, BaiWen-Pei
Language : English
Author: LemmersMarike, VerschoorMarianne Ac, KimBobae Veronica, HickeyMartha, VazquezJuan C, MolBen Willem J, NeilsonJames P
Language : English
Effect of progestogen for women with threatened miscarriage: a systematic review and meta-analysis.
Author: LiL, ZhangY, TanH, BaiY, FangF, FaramandA, ChongW, HaiY
Language : English
Author: MaNana, QinRongyan, QinWeili, LiaoMing, ZhaoYunxiao, HangFu, QinAiping
Language : English
Author: NagendraDivyah, GutmanSarah M, KoelperNathanael C, Loza-AvalosSandra E, SonalkarSarita, SchreiberCourtney A, HarvieHeidi S
Language : English
This site uses cookies. Visit our privacy policy page or click the link in any footer for more information and to change your preferences.