Effective treatment of suicide: A Synthesis of Findings from 67 Studies
- Home
- Effective treatment of suicide
This analysis is based on research papers included in PubMed, but medical research is constantly evolving and may not fully reflect the latest findings. There may also be biases towards certain research areas.
This information is not medical advice and is not a substitute for diagnosis or treatment by a physician. If you have concerns about "Effective treatment of suicide: A Synthesis of Findings from 67 Studies", please consult your doctor.
For NLM copyright information, please see Link to NLM Copyright Page
PubMed data is obtained via Hugging Face Datasets: Link to DatasetPlease check the disclaimer.
Major Findings
Suicide is a significant public health concern, and the majority of those who attempt suicide suffer from mental health disorders. 40 , 57 . Beyond traditional medication, therapies like seizure therapy and noninvasive brain stimulation have been used to treat such patients. However, the impact of these non-pharmaceutical treatments on suicidal thoughts and the occurrence of suicide remains unclear. 57 . This paper aims to provide an update on the effects of seizure therapy and noninvasive brain stimulation on suicidal thoughts.
Some studies have shown that cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is effective in reducing suicidal thoughts and behaviors. 17 , , 50 . Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) may also be effective for veterans with high suicidal thoughts. 40 . Furthermore, continuous communication through phone calls and letters for individuals who have attempted suicide could help reduce the risk of a subsequent attempt. 56 . Lithium is used as a maintenance treatment for mood disorders and might lower suicide rates. 5 . Clozapine may also significantly reduce suicidal behavior in patients with schizophrenia. 9 . However, it is unclear whether antidepressants can prevent suicides or suicide attempts, particularly during long-term use. 39 . There is also research indicating that psychotropic medication is not associated with a decrease in suicidal thoughts or suicide reattempts. 58 .
In the treatment of suicidal behavior, encouraging treatment engagement is critical. 43 , 37 . Communication between patients and their families can be a very effective way of preventing a second suicide attempt. 56 . Providing suicide risk assessments and guidelines for those at high risk is also important. 29 . Therapeutic alliance plays a significant role in therapeutic interventions for individuals who have attempted suicide. 44 .
Treatment Summary
Various treatments are being researched to treat suicidal thoughts and behaviors. Medication options include antidepressants, lithium, and clozapine. 5 , 9 , 39 , 58 . Non-medication therapies include CBT, DBT, seizure therapy, and noninvasive brain stimulation. 17 , , 40 , 50 , 57 . Furthermore, encouraging communication between patients and their families and promoting treatment engagement is crucial. 43 , 37 , 56 , 29 , 44 .
Benefits and Risks
Benefit Summary
Research suggests that treatments like CBT, DBT, continuous communication through phone calls and letters, lithium, and clozapine can help reduce suicidal thoughts and behaviors. 17 , , 40 , 50 , 56 , 5 , 9 . Encouraging communication between patients and their families and promoting treatment engagement are also important. 43 , 37 , 56 , 29 , 44 .
Risk Summary
Antidepressants may not prevent suicides or suicide attempts. 39 . Psychotropic medication may not be associated with a decrease in suicidal thoughts or suicide reattempts. 58 .
Comparison Between Studies
Commonalities
Many studies focus on reducing suicidal thoughts and behaviors. 17 , , 40 , 50 , 56 , 5 , 9 , 39 , 58 . They also highlight the importance of promoting treatment engagement. 43 , 37 , 56 , 29 , 44 .
Differences
The patient populations, treatments, and study designs vary across studies. 17 , , 40 , 50 , 56 , 5 , 9 , 39 , 58 , 43 , 37 , 56 , 29 , 44 .
Consistency and Contradictions in Findings
There is both consistency and contradiction in the research findings. Some studies show that treatments such as CBT, DBT, continuous communication through phone calls and letters, lithium, and clozapine help reduce suicidal thoughts and behaviors. 17 , , 40 , 50 , 56 , 5 , 9 . However, antidepressants may not prevent suicides or suicide attempts, and psychotropic medication may not be associated with a decrease in suicidal thoughts or suicide reattempts. 39 , 58 . These contradictions may be due to differences in the patient populations, treatments, and study designs.
Considerations for Real-World Application
If you are experiencing suicidal thoughts or behaviors, seek appropriate treatment. 17 , , 40 , 50 , 56 , 5 , 9 . If you are at high risk of suicide, consult a doctor. 29 . It is important to reach out to family and friends for support. 43 , 37 , 56 . Suicidal thoughts are treatable, and it is essential to remember that there is always hope.
Limitations of Current Research
There is still not enough research on the treatment of suicidal thoughts and behaviors. In particular, more research is needed on the effects of seizure therapy and noninvasive brain stimulation on suicidal thoughts. 57 . Research is also lacking on the effectiveness of therapeutic interventions for individuals who have attempted suicide. 36 . Furthermore, comparing research findings can be challenging due to differences in study designs, patient populations, and treatments.
Directions for Future Research
More research is needed on the effects of seizure therapy and noninvasive brain stimulation on suicidal thoughts. 57 . Research is also needed on the effectiveness of therapeutic interventions for individuals who have attempted suicide. 36 . Standardizing study designs, patient populations, and treatments would make comparing research findings easier.
Conclusion
Suicide is a significant public health concern, and individuals experiencing suicidal thoughts or behaviors should seek appropriate treatment. 17 , , 40 , 50 , 56 , 5 , 9 . If you are at high risk of suicide, consult a doctor. 29 . It is important to reach out to family and friends for support. 43 , 37 , 56 . Suicidal thoughts are treatable, and it is essential to remember that there is always hope.
Treatment List
CBT, DBT, seizure therapy, noninvasive brain stimulation, antidepressants, lithium, clozapine, continuous communication through phone calls and letters, communication with family, promoting treatment engagement
Benefit Keywords
Risk Keywords
Article Type
Author: WeluT C
Language : English
Author: SalkovskisP M, AthaC, StorerD
Language : English
Language : English
Psychosocial intervention following suicide attempt: a systematic review of treatment interventions.
Author: van der SandeR, BuskensE, AllartE, van der GraafY, van EngelandH
Language : English
Author: BurgessS, GeddesJ, HawtonK, TownsendE, JamisonK, GoodwinG
Language : English
Author: CorneliusJ R, SalloumI M, LynchK, ClarkD B, MannJ J
Language : English
Author: BurgessS, GeddesJ, HawtonK, TownsendE, JamisonK, GoodwinG
Language : English
Author: CederekeM, MontiK, OjehagenA
Language : English
Author: MeltzerHerbert Y, AlphsLarry, GreenAlan I, AltamuraA Carlo, AnandRavi, BertoldiAlberto, BourgeoisMarc, ChouinardGuy, IslamM Zahur, KaneJohn, KrishnanRanga, LindenmayerJ P, PotkinSteven,
Language : English
Author: SzantoKatalin, MulsantBenoit H, HouckPatricia, DewMary Amanda, ReynoldsCharles F
Language : English
Author: PotkinSteven G, AlphsLarry, HsuChuanchieh, KrishnanK Ranga Rama, AnandRavi, YoungFrederick K, MeltzerHerbert, GreenAlan,
Language : English
Author: HennenJohn, BaldessariniRoss J
Language : English
Author: SakinofskyIsaac
Language : English
Author: VannoySteven D, DubersteinPaul, CukrowiczKelly, LinElizabeth, FanMing-Yu, UnützerJürgen
Language : English
Author: TarrierNicholas, TaylorKatherine, GoodingPatricia
Language : English
Author: KrausJohn E, HorriganJoseph P, CarpenterDavid J, FongRegan, BarrettPamela S, DaviesJohn T
Language : English
Author: StanleyBarbara, BrownGregory, BrentDavid A, WellsKaren, PolingKim, CurryJohn, KennardBetsy D, WagnerAnn, CwikMary F, KlomekAnat Brunstein, GoldsteinTina, VitielloBenedetto, BarnettShannon, DanielStephanie, HughesJennifer
Language : English
Author: BrentDavid A, GreenhillLaurence L, ComptonScott, EmslieGraham, WellsKaren, WalkupJohn T, VitielloBenedetto, BuksteinOscar, StanleyBarbara, PosnerKelly, KennardBetsy D, CwikMary F, WagnerAnn, CoffeyBarbara, MarchJohn S, RiddleMark, GoldsteinTina, CurryJohn, BarnettShannon, CapassoLisa, ZelaznyJamie, HughesJennifer, ShenSa, GuggaS Sonia, TurnerJ Blake
Language : English
Author: van BeekWessel, KerkhofAd, BeekmanAartjan
Language : English
Author: van SpijkerBregje A J, van StratenAnnemieke, KerkhofAd J F M
Language : English
Author: GruatG, CottencinO, DucrocqF, DuhemS, VaivaG
Language : French
Author: AsarnowJoan Rosenbaum, BaraffLarry J, BerkMichele, GrobCharles S, Devich-NavarroMona, SuddathRobert, PiacentiniJohn C, Rotheram-BorusMary Jane, CohenDaniel, TangLingqi
Language : English
Author: CuijpersPim, de BeursDerek P, van SpijkerBregje A J, BerkingMatthias, AnderssonGerhard, KerkhofAd J F M
Language : English
Author: MorthorstBritt, KroghJesper, ErlangsenAnnette, AlberdiFrancisco, NordentoftMerete
Language : English
Author: Gómez-DuránEsperanza L, Martin-FumadóCarles, Hurtado-RuízGemma
Language : English
Author: GarlowSteven J, KinkeadBecky, ThaseMichael E, JuddLewis L, RushA John, YonkersKimberly A, KupferDavid J, FrankEllen, SchettlerPamela J, RapaportMark Hyman
Language : English
Author: HandleyTonelle E, Kay-LambkinFrances J, BakerAmanda L, LewinTerry J, KellyBrian J, InderKerry J, AttiaJohn R, KavanaghDavid J
Language : English
Author: CiprianiAndrea, GirlandaFrancesca, AgrimiEmilia, BarichelloAndrea, BeneduceRossella, BighelliIrene, BisoffiGiulia, BisognoAlfredo, BortolasoPaola, BosoMarianna, CalandraCarmela, CasconeLiliana, CorbascioCaterina, PariseVincenzo Fricchione, GardellinFrancesco, GennaroDaniele, HanifeBatul, LintasCamilla, LorussoMarina, LuchettaChiara, LuciiClaudio, CernutoFrancesco, TozziFiorella, MarsilioAlessandra, MaioFrancesca, MatteiChiara, MorettiDaniele, AppinoMaria Grazia, NosèMichela, OcchioneroGuglielmo, PapantiDuccio, PecileDamiano, PurgatoMarianna, PrestiaDavide, RestainoFrancesco, SciarmaTiziana, RubertoAlessandra, StrizzoloStefania, TamboriniStefania, TodarelloOrlando, ZieroSimona, ZotosSpyridon, BarbuiCorrado
Language : English
Author: CukrowiczKelly C, DubersteinPaul R, VannoySteven D, LinElizabeth H, UnützerJürgen
Language : English
Author: AndreassonKate, KroghJesper, RosenbaumBent, GluudChristian, JobesDavid A, NordentoftMerete
Language : English
Author: CollinsonMichelle, OwensDavid, BlenkironPaul, BurtonKayleigh, GrahamLiz, HatcherSimon, HouseAllan, MartinKatie, PembrokeLouise, ProtheroeDavid, TubeufSandy, FarrinAmanda
Language : English
Author: WeitzErica, HollonSteven D, KerkhofAd, CuijpersPim
Language : English
Author: HatcherSimon, SharonCynthia, HouseAllan, CollinsNicola, CollingsSunny, PillaiAvinesh
Language : English
Author: HaddockGillian, DaviesLinda, EvansEmma, EmsleyRichard, GoodingPatricia, HeaneyLisa, JonesSarah, KellyJames, MunroAilsa, PetersSarah, PrattDaniel, TarrierNicholas, WindfuhrKirsten, AwenatYvonne
Language : English
Author: DevenishBethany, BerkLesley, LewisAndrew J
Language : English
Author: Gysin-MaillartAnja, SchwabSimon, SoraviaLeila, MegertMillie, MichelKonrad
Language : English
Author: Ward-CiesielskiErin F, JonesConnor B, WielgusMadeline D, WilksChelsey R, LinehanMarsha M
Language : English
Author: MeerwijkEsther L, ParekhAmrita, OquendoMaria A, AllenI Elaine, FranckLinda S, LeeKathryn A
Language : English
Author: BraunCora, BschorTom, FranklinJeremy, BaethgeChristopher
Language : English
Author: GoodmanMarianne, BanthinDavid, BlairNicholas J, MascitelliKathryn A, WilsnackJaime, ChenJennifer, MessengerJulie W, Perez-RodriguezM Mercedes, TriebwasserJoseph, KoenigsbergHarold W, GoetzRaymond R, HazlettErin A, NewAntonia S
Language : English
Author: MichelKonrad, ValachLadislav, Gysin-MaillartAnja
Language : English
Cognitive-Behavioral Family Treatment for Suicide Attempt Prevention: A Randomized Controlled Trial.
Author: AsarnowJoan Rosenbaum, HughesJennifer L, BabevaKalina N, SugarCatherine A
Language : English
Author: Ward-CiesielskiErin F, TidikJulia A, EdwardsAmanda J, LinehanMarsha M
Language : English
Author: Dunster-PageCharlotte, HaddockGillian, WainwrightLaura, BerryKatherine
Language : English
Author: CanusoCarla M, SinghJaskaran B, FedgchinMaggie, AlphsLarry, LaneRosanne, LimPilar, PinterChristine, HoughDavid, SanacoraGerard, ManjiHusseini, DrevetsWayne C
Language : English
Author: McCauleyElizabeth, BerkMichele S, AsarnowJoan R, AdrianMolly, CohenJudith, KorslundKathyrn, AvinaClaudia, HughesJennifer, HarnedMelanie, GallopRobert, LinehanMarsha M
Language : English
Author: RybergWenche, ZahlPer-Henrik, DiepLien My, LandrøNils Inge, FosseRoar
Language : English
Author: RybergWenche, DiepLien My, LandrøNils Inge, FosseRoar
Language : English
Author: AwenatYvonne F, PetersSarah, GoodingPatricia A, PrattDaniel, HuggettCharlotte, HarrisKamelia, ArmitageChristopher J, HaddockGillian
Language : English
Author: BüscherRebekka, TorokMichelle, TerhorstYannik, SanderLasse
Language : English
Author: IonescuDawn F, FuDong-Jing, QiuXin, LaneRosanne, LimPilar, KasperSiegfried, HoughDavid, DrevetsWayne C, ManjiHusseini, CanusoCarla M
Language : English
Author: ChaïbLaurent S, Lopez-CastromanJorge, AbbarMocrane
Language : English
Author: RufinoNatalia C, FidalgoThiago M, Dos SantosJuliana P, TardelliVítor S, LimaMarcelo G, FrickLuana P, MirkovicBojan, da SilveiraDartiu X, CohenDavid
Language : English
Author: MalakoutiSeyed Kazem, NojomiMarzieh, GhanbariBehrooz, RasouliNafee, KhaleghparastShiva, FarahaniIda Ghaemmagham
Language : English
Author: WittKatrina, MadsenTrine, BerkMichael, DeanOlivia, ChanenAndrew, McGorryPatrick D, CottonSue, DaveyChristopher G, HetrickSarah
Language : English
Author: KatsivardaCecilia, AssimakopoulosKonstantinos, JelastopuluEleni
Language : English
Can seizure therapies and noninvasive brain stimulations prevent suicidality? A systematic review.
Author: ChenYiming, MagninCharline, BrunelinJérome, LeauneEdouard, FangYiru, PouletEmmanuel
Language : English
Author: MichelKonrad, Gysin-MaillartAnja, BreitSigrid, WaltherSebastian, PavlidouAnastasia
Language : English
Author: SullivanSarah R, MonahanMaureen F, MitchellEmily L, SpearsAngela Page, WalshSamantha, SzeszkoJake R, GromatskyMolly, StanleyBarbara, GoodmanMarianne
Language : English
Author: FreyLaura M, HuntQuintin A, RussonJody M, DiamondGuy
Language : English
Author: WilkinsonSamuel T, Trujillo DiazDaniel, RuppZachary W, KidambiAnubhav, RamirezKarina L, FloresJosé M, Avila-QuinteroVictor J, RheeT Greg, OlfsonMark, BlochMichael H
Language : English
Author: GutierrezPeter M, JohnsonLora, PodlogarMatthew C, HagmanStacy, MuehlerTanner A, HansonJetta, PiersonJonathan T, BrownAustin A, O'ConnorStephen
Language : English
Author: KatzIra R, RogersMalcolm P, LewRobert, ThwinSoe Soe, DorosGheorghe, AhearnEileen, OstacherMichael J, DeLisiLynn E, SmithEric G, RingerRobert J, FergusonRyan, HoffmanBrian, KaufmanJames S, PaikJulie M, ConradChester H, HolmbergErika F, BoneyTamara Y, HuangGrant D, LiangMatthew H,
Language : English
Author: RozekDavid C, BakerShelby N, RugoKelsi F, SteigerwaldVictoria L, SippelLauren M, HollidayRyan, RobergeErika M, HeldPhilip, MotaNatalie, SmithNoelle B
Language : English
Author: GibbonsRobert D, HurKwan, LavigneJill E, MannJ John
Language : English
Author: KabirHumayun, WaylandSarah, MapleMyfanwy
Language : English
Author: SanderLasse B, BeisemannMarie, DoeblerPhilipp, MicklitzHannah Moon, KerkhofAd, CuijpersPim, BatterhamPhilip, CalearAlison, ChristensenHelen, De JaegereEva, DomhardtMatthias, ErlangsenAnnette, Eylem-van BergeijkOzlem, HillRyan, MühlmannCharlotte, ÖsterleMarie, PettitJeremy, PortzkyGwendolyn, SteublLena, van SpijkerBregje, TigheJoseph, Werner-SeidlerAliza, BüscherRebekka
Language : English
This site uses cookies. Visit our privacy policy page or click the link in any footer for more information and to change your preferences.