Effective treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome: A Synthesis of Findings from 128 Studies
- Home
- Effective treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome
This analysis is based on research papers included in PubMed, but medical research is constantly evolving and may not fully reflect the latest findings. There may also be biases towards certain research areas.
This information is not medical advice and is not a substitute for diagnosis or treatment by a physician. If you have concerns about "Effective treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome: A Synthesis of Findings from 128 Studies", please consult your doctor.
For NLM copyright information, please see Link to NLM Copyright Page
PubMed data is obtained via Hugging Face Datasets: Link to DatasetPlease check the disclaimer.
Major Research Findings
Many studies have shown that there are both surgical and non-surgical treatments for carpal tunnel syndrome. Surgical treatment involves cutting the ligament in the carpal tunnel to relieve pressure on the median nerve. 35 , 22 , 90 , 97 , 19 , 32 , 23 , 66 , 6 , 8 , 74 , 98 , 113 Non-surgical treatment includes the use of wrist splints, steroid injections, and physical therapy. 35 , 22 , 58 , 63 , 84 , 52 , 79 , 126 , 55 , 27 , 7 , 24 , 83 , 50 , 12 , 39 , 5 , 26 , 88 Which treatment is more effective depends on the severity of the patient's symptoms and other factors. 26
Treatment Summary
Many studies have shown that there are both surgical and non-surgical treatments for carpal tunnel syndrome. Surgical treatment involves cutting the ligament in the carpal tunnel to relieve pressure on the median nerve. 35 , 22 , 90 , 97 , 19 , 32 , 23 , 66 , 6 , 8 , 74 , 98 , 113 Non-surgical treatment includes the use of wrist splints, steroid injections, and physical therapy. 35 , 22 , 58 , 63 , 84 , 52 , 79 , 126 , 55 , 27 , 7 , 24 , 83 , 50 , 12 , 39 , 5 , 26 , 88 Which treatment is more effective depends on the severity of the patient's symptoms and other factors. 26
Benefits and Risks
Benefit Summary
Surgical treatment for carpal tunnel syndrome is often effective in improving symptoms, as shown by multiple studies. 22 , 97 , 19 Surgical treatment can be expected to improve the function of the median nerve by releasing pressure in the carpal tunnel. 27 Surgical treatment has risks, such as scarring and infection, but these risks are considered relatively low. 90 Non-surgical treatment has the advantage of being less risky than surgical treatment. 7 , 24 However, the effects of non-surgical treatment may be shorter than those of surgical treatment. 58 Steroid injections for carpal tunnel syndrome have been shown to be effective in the short term, but long-term studies have shown that these effects do not last. 7 The use of wrist splints and exercises such as tendon and nerve gliding exercises may be effective in improving symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome. 24 , 50 , 39 Acupuncture, TDP irradiation, and Chinese herbal steaming and washing may be effective treatments for early symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome. 52
Risk Summary
Surgical treatment for carpal tunnel syndrome carries the risk of scarring and infection. 90 Steroid injections for carpal tunnel syndrome have been shown to be effective in the short term, but long-term studies have shown that these effects do not last. 7 Steroid injections also carry the risk of side effects such as osteoporosis and increased blood sugar. 55
Comparison Between Studies
Commonalities in Studies
Many studies have shown that both surgical and non-surgical treatments for carpal tunnel syndrome are effective. 22 , 97 , 35 , 83 , 26 However, the most effective treatment varies depending on the severity of the patient's symptoms and other factors. 26
Differences in Studies
There is variability in research findings when comparing the effectiveness of surgical and non-surgical treatments for carpal tunnel syndrome. 22 , 97 , 35 This variability is thought to be influenced by differences in the patient populations studied, the treatments used, and the study design. 26 There is also variability in research findings on the effectiveness of steroid injections for carpal tunnel syndrome. 58 , 7 This is thought to be influenced by differences in the injection method and the type of steroid used. 55 There are a number of different methods for performing carpal tunnel release surgery. 32 , 23 , 66 , 6 , 8 , 74 , 98 , 113 Studies have been conducted to compare the effectiveness and safety of these methods. 81
Consistency and Contradictions in Findings
Some contradictions have been observed in research comparing the effectiveness of surgical and non-surgical treatments for carpal tunnel syndrome. 22 , 97 , 35 For example, 22 found that surgical treatment was more effective in improving symptoms, while 97 found no significant difference between surgical and non-surgical treatment. 35 found no difference in symptom improvement after one year between surgical treatment and steroid injections. These contradictions are thought to be influenced by differences in the patient populations studied, the treatments used, and the study design. 26 There is also variability in research findings on the effectiveness of steroid injections for carpal tunnel syndrome. 58 , 7 This is thought to be influenced by differences in the injection method and the type of steroid used. 55
Points to Note in Applying Findings to Real Life
When choosing a treatment for carpal tunnel syndrome, it is important to consider the severity of the patient's symptoms and other factors. 26 Surgical treatment may be an option for severe cases or when non-surgical treatment has not been effective. 26 Non-surgical treatment may be appropriate for patients with mild to moderate symptoms. 83 It is essential to consult with your doctor to determine the best treatment for you. 26 , 83 If you are considering surgery, it is essential to get information from your doctor about the risks and complications of surgery. 90 If you are undergoing non-surgical treatment, it is essential to continue using wrist splints and performing exercises such as tendon and nerve gliding exercises. 24 , 50 , 39 If your symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome do not improve, it is essential to consult with your doctor to discuss revising your treatment plan. 26 , 83
Current Research Limitations
Variability in research findings comparing the effectiveness of surgical and non-surgical treatments for carpal tunnel syndrome is influenced by differences in the patient populations studied, the treatments used, and the study design. 26 There is also variability in research findings on the effectiveness of steroid injections for carpal tunnel syndrome. 58 , 7 This is thought to be influenced by differences in the injection method and the type of steroid used. 55 More research is needed to identify the optimal treatment for carpal tunnel syndrome. 83 , 72
Future Research Directions
Variability in research findings comparing the effectiveness of surgical and non-surgical treatments for carpal tunnel syndrome is influenced by differences in the patient populations studied, the treatments used, and the study design. 26 More research is needed to identify the optimal treatment for carpal tunnel syndrome. 83 , 72 Specifically, research is needed that tracks the long-term effects of steroid injections for carpal tunnel syndrome and compares different surgical methods. 55 , 81
Conclusion
There are both surgical and non-surgical treatments for carpal tunnel syndrome, and the best option depends on the severity of the patient's symptoms and other factors. 26 It is essential to consult with your doctor to determine the best treatment for you. 26 , 83 If you are considering surgery, it is essential to get information from your doctor about the risks and complications of surgery. 90 If your symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome do not improve, it is essential to consult with your doctor to discuss revising your treatment plan. 26 , 83
Treatment List
Here are the treatment keywords based on the research: * Surgical treatment * Carpal tunnel release * Flexor tenosynovectomy * Non-surgical treatment * Wrist splint * Steroid injection * Physical therapy * Tendon and nerve gliding exercises * Ultrasound therapy * Acupuncture * TDP irradiation * Chinese herbal medicine * Warm compress * Kinesio taping * Pregabalin
Benefit Keywords
Risk Keywords
Article Type
Author: MackinnonS E, McCabeS, MurrayJ F, SzalaiJ P, KellyL, NovakC, KinB, BurkeG M
Language : English
Author: HolmgrenH, RabowL
Language : English
Author: HerrenD B, SimmenB R
Language : German
Author: SucherB M
Language : English
Author: SpoonerG R, DesaiH B, AngelJ F, ReederB A, DonatJ R
Language : English
Author: BrownR A, GelbermanR H, SeilerJ G, AbrahamssonS O, WeilandA J, UrbaniakJ R, SchoenfeldD A, FurcoloD
Language : English
Author: GirlandaP, DattolaR, VenutoC, MangiapaneR, NicolosiC, MessinaC
Language : English
Author: HoefnagelsW A, van KleefJ G, MastenbroekG G, de BlokJ A, BreukelmanA J, de KromM C
Language : Dutch
Ultrasound treatment for treating the carpal tunnel syndrome: randomised "sham" controlled trial.
Author: EbenbichlerG R, ReschK L, NicolakisP, WiesingerG F, UhlF, GhanemA H, FialkaV
Language : English
Author: JimenezD F, GibbsS R, ClapperA T
Language : English
Author: ChangM H, ChiangH T, LeeS S, GerL P, LoY K
Language : English
Author: OztasO, TuranB, BoraI, KarakayaM K
Language : English
Author: FeuersteinM, BurrellL M, MillerV I, LincolnA, HuangG D, BergerR
Language : English
Author: BurkeD T, BurkeM A, BellR, StewartG W, MehdiR S, KimH J
Language : English
Author: MarshallS, TardifG, AshworthN
Language : English
Author: Tal-AkabiA, RushtonA
Language : English
Systematic review of randomized clinical trials of surgical treatment for carpal tunnel syndrome.
Author: GerritsenA A, UitdehaagB M, van GeldereD, ScholtenR J, de VetH C, BouterL M
Language : English
Author: GerritsenA A, ScholtenR J, AssendelftW J, KuiperH, de VetH C, BouterL M
Language : English
Author: ShumCharlotte, ParisienMay, StrauchRobert J, RosenwasserMelvin P
Language : English
Author: VerdugoR J, SalinasR S, CastilloJ, CeaJ G
Language : English
Author: JordanRachel, CarterTim, CumminsCarole
Language : English
Author: GerritsenAnnette A M, de VetHenrica C W, ScholtenRob J P M, BertelsmannFrits W, de KromMarc C T F M, BouterLex M
Language : English
Author: ScholtenR J P M, GerritsenA A M, UitdehaagB M J, van GeldereD, de VetH C W, BouterL M
Language : English
Author: O'ConnorD, MarshallS, Massy-WestroppN
Language : English
Author: VieraAnthony J
Language : English
Author: VerdugoR J, SalinasR S, CastilloJ, CeaJ G
Language : English
Author: BorischN, HaussmannP
Language : English
Author: ArmstrongTimothy, DevorWilliam, BorschelLaura, ContrerasRichard
Language : English
Author: GrahamRoger G, HudsonDonald A, SolomonsMichael, SingerMartin
Language : English
Author: HuiA C F, WongS M, TangA, MokV, HungL K, WongK S
Language : English
Author: SevimS, DoguO, CamdevirenH, KaleagasiH, AralM, ArslanE, MilcanA
Language : English
Author: ScholtenR J P M, GerritsenA A M, UitdehaagB M J, van GeldereD, de VetH C W, BouterL M
Language : English
Author: MartinBrook I, LevensonLinda M, HollingworthWilliam, KliotMichel, HeagertyPatrick J, TurnerJudith A, JarvikJeffrey G
Language : English
Author: ZhaoHong, ZhaoYu, TianYe, YangBo, QiuGui-Xing
Language : Chinese
Author: Ly-PenDomingo, AndréuJosé-Luis, de BlasGema, Sánchez-OlasoAlberto, MillánIsabel
Language : English
Author: AygülRecep, UlviHizir, KarataySaliha, DenizOrhan, VarogluAsuman Orhan
Language : English
Author: HuiA C F, WongS, LeungC H, TongP, MokV, PoonD, Li-TsangC W, WongL K, BoetR
Language : English
Author: HabibGeorge S, BadarnySamih, RawashdehHanna
Language : English
Author: BaysalO, AltayZ, OzcanC, ErtemK, YologluS, KayhanA
Language : English
Author: MishraSanjay, PrabhakarSudesh, LalVivek, ModiManish, DasChandi P, KhuranaDheeraj
Language : English
Author: SiegmethAlexander W, Hopkinson-WoolleyJames A
Language : English
Author: NalamachuSrinivas, CrockettR S, GammaitoniArnold R, GouldErrol M
Language : English
Author: PiazziniD B, AprileI, FerraraP E, BertoliniC, TonaliP, MaggiL, RabiniA, PiantelliS, PaduaL
Language : English
Author: TianYe, ZhaoHong, WangTing
Language : English
Author: ScholtenR J P M, Mink van der MolenA, UitdehaagB M J, BouterL M, de VetH C W
Language : English
Author: MoraskaAlbert, ChandlerClint, Edmiston-SchaetzelAmanda, FranklinGaye, CalendaElaine L, EneboBrian
Language : English
Author: Medina McKeonJennifer M, YancosekKathleen E
Language : English
Author: VerdugoRenato J, SalinasRodrigo A, CastilloJosé L, CeaJosé G
Language : English
Author: StepićNenad, NovakovićMarjan, MartićVesna, PerićDusan
Language : English
Author: BardakAyşe N, AlpMehmet, ErhanBelgin, PakerNurdan, KayaBetül, OnalAyşe E
Language : English
Surgery versus non-surgical therapy for carpal tunnel syndrome: a randomised parallel-group trial.
Author: JarvikJeffrey G, ComstockBryan A, KliotMichel, TurnerJudith A, ChanLeighton, HeagertyPatrick J, HollingworthWilliam, KerriganCarolyn L, DeyoRichard A
Language : English
Author: ZhangCui-yan, WangYan-xiang
Language : Chinese
Author: AlfonsoCalogero, JannStefano, MassaRoberto, TorreggianiAldo
Language : English
Author: CaiDe-Feng
Language : English
Author: FlondellMagnus, HoferManfred, BjörkJonas, AtroshiIsam
Language : English
Author: HuisstedeBionka M, HoogvlietPeter, RandsdorpManon S, GlerumSuzanne, van MiddelkoopMarienke, KoesBart W
Language : English
Author: HuisstedeBionka M, RandsdorpManon S, CoertJ Henk, GlerumSuzanne, van MiddelkoopMarienke, KoesBart W
Language : English
Author: Peters-VeluthamaningalCyriac, WintersJan C, GroenierKlaas H, Meyboom-de JongBetty
Language : English
Author: YangChun-Pai, WangNai-Hwei, LiTsai-Chung, HsiehChing-Liang, ChangHen-Hong, HwangKai-Lin, KoWang-Sheng, ChangMing-Hong
Language : English
Author: KaradaşOmer, TokFatih, UlaşUmit Hidir, OdabaşiZeki
Language : English
Author: CaliandroPietro, La TorreGiuseppe, PaduaRoberto, GianniniFabio, PaduaLuca
Language : English
Author: ShiQiyun, MacDermidJoy C
Language : English
Author: KamanliA, BezgincanM, KayaA
Language : English
Author: O'ConnorDenise, PageMatthew J, MarshallShawn C, Massy-WestroppNicola
Language : English
Author: YaoElisa, GerritzPeter K, HenricsonErik, AbreschTed, KimJorge, HanJay, WangKenten, ZhaoHolly
Language : English
Author: AslaniHamid Reza, AlizadehKhalil, EajaziAlireza, KarimiAmin, KarimiMohammad Hossein, ZaferaniZohreh, Hosseini KhamenehSeyed Mehdi
Language : English
Author: PageMatthew J, O'ConnorDenise, PittVeronica, Massy-WestroppNicola
Language : English
Author: CaliandroPietro, La TorreGiuseppe, PaduaRoberto, GianniniFabio, PaduaLuca
Language : English
Author: EjiriSoichi, KikuchiShin-ichi, MaruyaMasato, SekiguchiYasufumi, KawakamiRyoichi, KonnoShin-ichi
Language : English
Author: Jerosch-HeroldChristina, ShepstoneLee, MillerLeanne
Language : English
Author: KimDong Hwee, JangJi Eun, ParkByung Kyu
Language : English
Author: PetersSusan, PageMatthew J, CoppietersMichel W, RossMark, JohnstonVenerina
Language : English
Author: SoltaniAli M, AllanBassan J, BestMatthew J, MirHaaris S, PanthakiZubin J
Language : English
Author: TaralloMauro, FinoPasquale, SorvilloValentina, ParisiPaola, ScuderiNicolò
Language : English
Author: VasiliadisHaris S, GeorgoulasPetros, ShrierIan, SalantiGeorgia, ScholtenRob J P M
Language : English
Author: MeemsMargreet, Den OudstenBrenda, MeemsBerend-Jan, PopVictor
Language : English
Author: BakerNancy A, LivengoodHeather M
Language : English
Author: ZuoDongqing, ZhouZifei, WangHongsheng, LiaoYuxin, ZhengLongpo, HuaYingqi, CaiZhengdong
Language : English
Author: AwanAbdus Saboor, KhanAlamzeb, AfridiSikandar Aziz, KhanInam Ullah, BhattiSajid Nazir, AhmedEhtisham, MuhammadGul, KhanRao Suhail, SultanShahid, LodhiFahad Saqib
Language : English
Author: GümüştaşSeyit Ali, EkmekçiBurcu, TosunHaci Bayram, OrakMehmet Müfit, BeklerHalil İbrahim
Language : English
Author: VasiliadisHaris S, NikolakopoulouAdriani, ShrierIan, LunnMichael P, BrassingtonRuth, ScholtenRob J P, SalantiGeorgia
Language : English
Author: PetersSusan, PageMatthew J, CoppietersMichel W, RossMark, JohnstonVenerina
Language : English
Author: Jiménez Del BarrioS, Bueno GraciaE, Hidalgo GarcíaC, Estébanez de MiguelE, Tricás MorenoJ M, Rodríguez MarcoS, Ceballos LaitaL
Language : English
Author: Geler KülcüDuygu, BursaliCanan, Aktaşİlknur, Bozkurt AlpSelin, Ünlü ÖzkanFeyza, AkpinarPınar
Language : English
Author: Castro-MenéndezM, Pagazaurtundúa-GómezS, Pena-PazS, Huici-IzcoR, Rodríguez-CasasN, Montero-ViéitesA
Language : English
Author: LewisKarina J, RossLeo, CoppietersMichel W, VicenzinoBill, SchmidAnnina B
Language : English
Author: RenYi-Ming, WangXi-Shan, WeiZhi-Jian, FanBao-You, LinWei, ZhouXian-Hu, FengShi-Qing
Language : English
Author: CaliandroPietro, La TorreGiuseppe, PaduaRoberto, GianniniFabio, PaduaLuca
Language : English
Author: BurgerMarlette, KrielRéna, DamonAndrea, AbelAmy, BansdaAnisha, WakensMarinique, ErnstzenDawn
Language : English
Author: BullerMitchell, SchulzSteven, KasdanMorton, WilhelmiBradon J
Language : English
Author: OrdahanBanu, KarahanAli Yavuz
Language : English
Author: De KleermaekerFloriaan G C M, MeulsteeJan, ClaesFranka, KasiusKristel M, VerhagenWim I M
Language : English
Author: MeemsMargreet, SpekViola, KopWillem J, MeemsBerend-Jan, VisserLeo H, PopVictor J M
Language : English
Author: RaeissadatSeyed Ahmad, KarimzadehAfshin, HashemiMasoud, BagherzadehLeila
Language : English
Author: Mansiz KaplanBasak, AkyuzGulseren, KokarSerdar, YagciIlker
Language : English
Author: EvangelistaMaurizio, Cilli, De VitisR, MiliternoA, FanfaniF
Language : English
Author: ShiQiyun, BobosPavlos, LaloneEmily A, WarrenLaura, MacDermidJoy C
Language : English
Author: LiGaocen, KongLingde, KouNingzhao, WangYanxue, YuKunlun, BaiJiangbo, TianDehu
Language : English
Author: SennaMohammad K, ShaatReham M, AliAlaa Ali Awad
Language : English
Author: MottaghiMohammad, ZareMostafa, PahlavanhosseiniHamid, MottaghiMina
Language : English
Author: Bahrami-TaghanakiHamidreza, AziziHoda, HasanabadiHosein, JokarMohamad Hassan, IranmaneshAmir, Khorsand-VakilzadehAli, Badiee-AvalShapour
Language : English
Author: EzzatiKamran, LaaksoE-Liisa, SaberiAlia, Yousefzadeh ChabokShahrokh, NasiriEbrahim, Bakhshayesh EghbaliBabak
Language : English
Author: ElawamyAbdelraheem, HassanienManal, HamedAhmed, RoushdyAl Shimaa Ismael, AbassNisreen Adel, MohammedGhada, HasanMohamed Raouf Abdel Razek, KamelEmad Zarief
Language : English
Author: LiYueying, LuoWenqi, WuGuangzhi, CuiShusen, ZhangZhan, GuXiaosong
Language : English
Author: ShemKazuko, WongJoseph, DirlikovBenjamin
Language : English
Author: KrauseDonnamarie, RollShawn C, Javaherian-DysingerHeather, DaherNoha
Language : English
Author: AkgolGurkan, ElbastiMuhammet Sahin, GulkesenArif, AlkanGokhan, KayaArzu, UlusoyHasan
Language : English
Author: Hernández-SecorúnMar, Montaña-CortésRaquel, Hidalgo-GarcíaCésar, Rodríguez-SanzJacobo, Corral-de-ToroJaime, Monti-BallanoSofia, Hamam-AlcoberSami, Tricás-MorenoJosé Miguel, Lucha-LópezMaría Orosia
Language : English
Author: de MoraesVinícius Ynoe, QueirozJesus, Raduan-NetoJorge, FernandesMarcela, OkamuraAldo, BellotiJoão Carlos
Language : English
Author: AbdolrazaghiHossein Ali, KhansariMahmoud, MirshahiMaryam, Ahmadi PishkuhiMahin
Language : English
Author: Aminian-FarAtefeh, PahlevanDaryoush, KohnegiFatemeh Maleki
Language : English
Author: ChiangJenny, AnVincent Vinh Gia, GrahamDavid, LawsonRichard, SivakumarBrahman
Language : English
A Systematic Review of the Outcomes of Carpal Ligament Release in Severe Carpal Tunnel Syndrome.
Author: MeyersAbigail, AnnunziataMichael J, RampazzoAntonio, Bassiri GharbBahar
Language : English
Author: MacDonaldEilidh, ReaPaul M
Language : English
Author: ChouRaymond C, RobinsonDavid M, HomerScott
Language : English
Author: GräfJulia Katharina, LüdtkeKerstin, WollesenBettina
Language : German
Author: IjazMuhammad Junaid, KarimiHossein, AhmadAshfaq, GillaniSyed Amer, AnwarNaveed, ChaudharyMuhammad Asad
Language : English
Author: DuJihang, YuanQiang, WangXiao-Yan, QianJun-Hui, AnJie, DaiQian, YanXiang-Yun, XuBojun, LuoJian, WangHao-Zhong
Language : English
Outcomes of bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome treatment - A systematic review and meta-analysis.
Author: GeorgetoS M, PicharskiG L, AndrausR A C, da SilvaR A, NgomoS, FernandesK B P
Language : English
Author: Jiménez-Del-BarrioSandra, Ceballos-LaitaLuis, Bueno-GraciaElena, Rodríguez-MarcoSonia, Caudevilla-PoloSantos, Estébanez-de-MiguelElena
Language : English
Author: EberlinKyle R, DyChristopher J, FischerMark D, GluckJames L, KaplanF Thomas D, McDonaldThomas J, MillerLarry E, PalmerAlexander, WalkerMarc E, WattJames F
Language : English
Author: CavalcanteMarcelo Cortês, MoraesVinicius Ynoe de, OsésGuilherme Ladeira, NakachimaLuis Renato, BellotiJoão Carlos
Language : English
Author: AshworthNigel L, BlandJeremy D P, ChapmanKristine M, TardifGaetan, AlbarqouniLoai, NagendranArjuna
Language : English
Author: PanathoopArachaphon, SaengsuwanJittima, VichiansiriRatana
Language : English
Author: D'OrioMarco, De VitisRocco, TaccardoGiuseppe, RocchiLorenzo, FerrariFederico, PernaAndrea, PassiatoreMarco
Language : English
Author: BismayaKumar, SinghVarun Kumar, PathakAbhishek, KumarAnand, MishraVijaya Nath, JoshiDeepika, ChaurasiaRameshwar Nath
Language : English
Author: ZhouTianQi, WuZhuoRao, GouXingYun, XiaHaiSha, DingJiLin, AiShuangChun
Language : English
Author: NadarMohammed Sh, AlotaibiNaser, ManeeFahad
Language : English
This site uses cookies. Visit our privacy policy page or click the link in any footer for more information and to change your preferences.