Effective treatment of panic disorder: A Synthesis of Findings from 136 Studies
- Home
- Effective treatment of panic disorder
This analysis is based on research papers included in PubMed, but medical research is constantly evolving and may not fully reflect the latest findings. There may also be biases towards certain research areas.
This information is not medical advice and is not a substitute for diagnosis or treatment by a physician. If you have concerns about "Effective treatment of panic disorder: A Synthesis of Findings from 136 Studies", please consult your doctor.
For NLM copyright information, please see Link to NLM Copyright Page
PubMed data is obtained via Hugging Face Datasets: Link to DatasetPlease check the disclaimer.
Major Research Findings
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is widely recognized as an effective treatment for panic disorder. 103 investigated the efficacy of brief CBT for panic disorder patients presenting to emergency departments with chest pain, suggesting its effectiveness. 104 indicated that an 8-day intensive treatment for adolescents with panic disorder and agoraphobia can alleviate symptoms of comorbid psychiatric diagnoses, particularly specific phobias, generalized anxiety disorder, and social phobia. 110 examined the rate and shape of change in panic severity, fear, and avoidance symptoms across an 8-day intensive CBT for adolescents, revealing a clear trajectory of improvement. 93 found that internet-based CBT is as effective as face-to-face CBT for panic disorder and agoraphobia. 84 provided further support for the efficacy of internet-based CBT, demonstrating its effectiveness in reducing panic disorder symptoms, panic-related cognitions, negative affect, and the number of GP visits. 114 highlighted the role of self-efficacy and anxiety sensitivity as mechanisms of change during CBT for panic disorder. 73 suggested that self-directed treatment with brief therapist contact is a viable option for many individuals with panic disorder.
Treatment Summary
103 investigated the efficacy of brief CBT for panic disorder patients presenting to emergency departments with chest pain, suggesting its effectiveness. 104 indicated that an 8-day intensive treatment for adolescents with panic disorder and agoraphobia can alleviate symptoms of comorbid psychiatric diagnoses, particularly specific phobias, generalized anxiety disorder, and social phobia. 93 found that internet-based CBT is as effective as face-to-face CBT for panic disorder and agoraphobia. 84 provided further support for the efficacy of internet-based CBT, demonstrating its effectiveness in reducing panic disorder symptoms, panic-related cognitions, negative affect, and the number of GP visits. 73 suggested that self-directed treatment with brief therapist contact is a viable option for many individuals with panic disorder.
Benefits and Risks
Benefits Summary
CBT is widely recognized as an effective treatment for panic disorder. 103 investigated the efficacy of brief CBT for panic disorder patients presenting to emergency departments with chest pain, suggesting its effectiveness. 104 indicated that an 8-day intensive treatment for adolescents with panic disorder and agoraphobia can alleviate symptoms of comorbid psychiatric diagnoses, particularly specific phobias, generalized anxiety disorder, and social phobia. 110 examined the rate and shape of change in panic severity, fear, and avoidance symptoms across an 8-day intensive CBT for adolescents, revealing a clear trajectory of improvement. 93 found that internet-based CBT is as effective as face-to-face CBT for panic disorder and agoraphobia. 84 provided further support for the efficacy of internet-based CBT, demonstrating its effectiveness in reducing panic disorder symptoms, panic-related cognitions, negative affect, and the number of GP visits. 114 highlighted the role of self-efficacy and anxiety sensitivity as mechanisms of change during CBT for panic disorder. 73 suggested that self-directed treatment with brief therapist contact is a viable option for many individuals with panic disorder.
Risks Summary
While CBT is generally safe, some individuals may experience heightened anxiety or discomfort during the process. 50 compared three treatment modalities for panic disorder patients resistant to exposure therapy, finding that exposure therapy alone might be superior in some cases. However, patients who do not respond to exposure may have poor tolerance and compliance with pharmacological treatment, and may not achieve remission with imipramine or cognitive therapy.
Comparison Across Studies
Commonalities
These studies consistently suggest that CBT is an effective treatment for panic disorder. They also indicate the potential of internet-based CBT as an alternative to face-to-face CBT.
Differences
The studies vary in terms of the characteristics of participants, specific treatments, and research methodologies. For example, 103 focused on emergency department patients with chest pain, while 104 focused on adolescents. 93 found that internet-based CBT was comparable to face-to-face CBT, while 84 suggested that internet-based CBT might be even more effective.
Consistency and Contradictions
While these studies consistently suggest that CBT is an effective treatment, the specific details of treatment and patient characteristics influence outcomes. Some studies highlight factors that can impact CBT effectiveness, such as resistance to exposure therapy and medication tolerance.
Applying Results to Everyday Life
Individuals struggling with panic disorder should be aware that CBT can be an effective treatment option. However, it requires effort and active participation. CBT may not be effective for everyone, and factors like resistance to exposure therapy or medication tolerance should be considered.
Limitations of Current Research
These studies have limitations, including small sample sizes, variations in treatment details, and short follow-up periods, which make it difficult to generalize findings.
Future Research Directions
Future research should utilize larger samples, compare different treatment variations in more detail, and conduct longer follow-up studies. Further exploration of factors influencing CBT effectiveness, such as resistance to exposure therapy and medication tolerance, is also crucial.
Conclusion
Panic disorder is a treatable condition with various treatment options, including CBT. If you are experiencing panic disorder symptoms, consult a physician or mental health professional for a proper diagnosis and treatment plan.
Treatment List
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT)Internet-based CBTExposure TherapyPharmacological Treatment (e.g. imipramine)
Benefit Keywords
Risk Keywords
Article Type
Author: SwinsonR P, SouliosC, CoxB J, KuchK
Language : English
Author: MaierW, RothS M, ArgyleN, BullerR, LavoriP, BrandonS, BenkertO
Language : English
Author: BullerR, MaierW, GoldenbergI M, LavoriP W, BenkertO
Language : English
Author: MaierW, RosenbergR, ArgyleN, BullerR, RothM, BrandonS, BenkertO
Language : English
Author: MellergårdM, LorentzenK, BechP, OttossonJ O, RosenbergR
Language : English
Author: RosenbergN K, MellergårdM, RosenbergR, BeckP, OttossonJ O
Language : English
Author: RosenbergR, BechP, MellergårdM, OttossonJ O
Language : English
Author: NoyesR, ReichJ H, SuelzerM, ChristiansenJ
Language : English
Author: DeltitoJ A, ArgyleN, KlermanG L
Language : English
Author: DeltitoJ A, ArgyleN, BullerR, NutzingerD, OttossonJ O, BrandonS, MellergardM, SheraD
Language : English
Author: MattickR P, AndrewsG, Hadzi-PavlovicD, ChristensenH
Language : English
Author: AlbusM, LecrubierY, MaierW, BullerR, RosenbergR, HippiusH
Language : English
Author: de RuiterC, RykenH, GarssenB, KraaimaatF
Language : English
Author: TyrerP, SeivewrightN, MurphyS, FergusonB, KingdonD, BarczakP, BrothwellJ, DarlingC, GregoryS, JohnsonA L
Language : English
Author: LesserI M, RubinR T, PecknoldJ C, RifkinA, SwinsonR P, LydiardR B, BurrowsG D, NoyesR, DuPontR L
Language : English
Author: TaylorC B, KenigsbergM L, RobinsonJ M
Language : English
Author: ShearM K, LeonA C, PollackM H, RosenbaumJ F, KellerM B
Language : English
Author: CraskeM G, MaidenbergE, BystritskyA
Language : English
Author: TelchM J, SchmidtN B, JaimezT L, JacquinK M, HarringtonP J
Language : English
Author: OstL G, WestlingB E
Language : English
Author: BaşoğluM, MarksI M, SwinsonR P, NoshirvaniH, O'SullivanG, KuchK
Language : English
Author: BaşoğluM, MarksI M, KiliçC, SwinsonR P, NoshirvaniH, KuchK, O'SullivanG
Language : English
Author: BaşoğluM, MarksI M, KiliçC, BrewinC R, SwinsonR P
Language : English
Author: ClarkD M, SalkovskisP M, HackmannA, MiddletonH, AnastasiadesP, GelderM
Language : English
Author: BeckJ G, StanleyM A, BaldwinL E, DeagleE A, AverillP M
Language : English
Author: LidrenD M, WatkinsP L, GouldR A, ClumG A, AsterinoM, TullochH L
Language : English
Author: BlackD W, WesnerR B, GabelJ, BowersW, MonahanP
Language : English
Author: PollackM H, OttoM W, SachsG S, LeonA, ShearM K, DeltitoJ A, KellerM B, RosenbaumJ F
Language : English
Author: ClumG A, SurlsR
Language : English
Author: OstL G, WestlingB E, HellströmK
Language : English
Author: WoodmanC L, NoyesR, BallengerJ C, LydiardR B, SieversG, MihalkoD
Language : English
Author: ShearM K, PilkonisP A, CloitreM, LeonA C
Language : English
Author: SpiegelD A, BruceT J, GreggS F, NuzzarelloA
Language : English
Author: RickelsK, DowningR, SchweizerE, HassmanH
Language : English
Author: LepolaU M, RimónR H, RiekkinenP J
Language : English
Author: PollackM H, OttoM W, TesarG E, CohenL S, Meltzer-BrodyS, RosenbaumJ F
Language : English
Author: BlackD W, WesnerR, BowersW, GabelJ
Language : English
Author: SchweizerE, RickelsK, WeissS, ZavodnickS
Language : English
Maintenance drug treatment for panic disorder. II. Short- and long-term outcome after drug taper.
Author: RickelsK, SchweizerE, WeissS, ZavodnickS
Language : English
Author: TelchM J, LucasJ A, SchmidtN B, HannaH H, LaNae JaimezT, LucasR A
Language : English
Author: WiborgI M, DahlA A
Language : English
Acute treatment response in outpatients with panic disorder: high versus low depressive symptoms.
Author: BlackD W, WesnerR, BowersW, MonahanP, GabelJ
Language : English
Author: ArntzA, van den HoutM
Language : English
Author: BouchardS, GauthierJ, LabergeB, FrenchD, PelletierM H, GodboutC
Language : English
Author: ScheibeG, AlbusM
Language : English
Author: BouvardM, MollardE, GuerinJ, CottrauxJ
Language : English
Author: CraskeM G, RoweM, LewinM, Noriega-DimitriR
Language : English
Author: HoffartA, HedleyL M
Language : English
Author: UhlenhuthE H, MatuzasW, WarnerT D, ThompsonP M
Language : English
Author: FavaG A, SavronG, ZieleznyM, GrandiS, RafanelliC, ContiS
Language : English
Author: SharpD M, PowerK G, SimpsonR J, SwansonV, AnsteeJ A
Language : English
Author: HoffartA
Language : English
Author: BrownG K, BeckA T, NewmanC F, BeckJ S, TranG Q
Language : English
Author: van BalkomA J, BakkerA, SpinhovenP, BlaauwB M, SmeenkS, RuesinkB
Language : English
Follow-up on the treatment of panic disorder with or without agoraphobia: a quantitative review.
Author: BakkerA, van BalkomA J, SpinhovenP, BlaauwB M, van DyckR
Language : English
Author: HofmannS G, ShearM K, BarlowD H, GormanJ M, HershbergerD, PattersonM, WoodsS W
Language : English
Author: MichelsonD, LydiardR B, PollackM H, TamuraR N, HoogS L, TepnerR, DemitrackM A, TollefsonG D
Language : English
Author: de BeursE, van BalkomA J, Van DyckR, LangeA
Language : English
Author: LoerchB, Graf-MorgensternM, HautzingerM, SchlegelS, HainC, SandmannJ, BenkertO
Language : English
Author: MichelsonD, PollackM, LydiardR B, TamuraR, TepnerR, TollefsonG
Language : English
Author: ClarkD M, SalkovskisP M, HackmannA, WellsA, LudgateJ, GelderM
Language : English
Author: BakkerA, van DyckR, SpinhovenP, van BalkomA J
Language : English
Author: BowenR C, D'ArcyC, KeeganD, SenthilselvanA
Language : English
Author: AzharM Z
Language : English
Author: TeuschL, BöhmeH, FinkeJ
Language : German
Author: SharpD M, PowerK G, SwansonV
Language : English
Author: Lotufo-NetoF, BernikM, RamosR T, AndradeL, GorensteinC, CordasT, MeloM, GentilV
Language : English
Author: ShearM K, HouckP, GreenoC, MastersS
Language : English
Author: KampmanMirjam, KeijsersGer P J, HoogduinCees A L, HendriksGert-Jan
Language : English
Author: FrankEllen, CyranowskiJill M, RucciPaola, ShearM Katherine, FagioliniAndrea, ThaseMichael E, CassanoGiovanni B, GrochocinskiVictoria J, KostelnikBryan, KupferDavid J
Language : English
Author: Roy-ByrnePeter P, RussoJoan, CowleyDeborah S, KatonWayne J
Language : English
Author: CraskeMichelle G, DeColaJoseph P, SachsAndrei D, PontilloDeborah C
Language : English
Mastery of Your Anxiety and Panic and brief therapist contact in the treatment of panic disorder.
Author: HeckerJeffrey E, LoseeMelinda C, Roberson-NayRoxann, MakiKristin
Language : English
Author: BergerPeter, SachsGabriele, AmeringMichaela, HolzingerAnita, BankierBettina, KatschnigHeinz
Language : English
Author: BandelowBorwin, BehnkeKirsten, LenoirSergio, HendriksG J, AlkinTunc, GoebelClaus, ClaryCathryn M
Language : English
Author: DannonPinhas N, Gon-UsishkinM, GelbertA, LowengrubK, GrunhausL
Language : English
Author: AddisMichael E, HatgisChristina, KrasnowAaron D, JacobKaren, BourneLeslie, MansfieldAbigail
Language : English
Author: MavissakalianMatig R
Language : English
Author: OstLars-Göran, ThulinUlrika, RamneröJonas
Language : English
Author: SimonNaomi M, OttoMichael W, SmitsJasper A J, NicolaouD Colette, ReeseHannah E, PollackMark H
Language : English
Author: MarchandA, GermainV
Language : French
Author: Roy-ByrnePeter P, CraskeMichelle G, SteinMurray B, SullivanGreer, BystritskyAlexander, KatonWayne, GolinelliDaniela, SherbourneCathy D
Language : English
Author: HollifieldMichael, ThompsonPeter M, RuizJames E, UhlenhuthE H
Language : English
Author: KleinBritt, RichardsJeffrey C, AustinDavid W
Language : English
Author: CraskeMichelle G, GolinelliDaniela, SteinMurray B, Roy-ByrnePeter, BystritskyAlexander, SherbourneCathy
Language : English
Author: KatonWayne, RussoJoan, SherbourneCathy, SteinMurray B, CraskeMichelle, FanMing-Yu, Roy-ByrnePeter
Language : English
[Treatment of anxiety syndrome. A systematic literature review. Summary and conclusions by the SBU].
Author: von KnorringLars, ThelanderSten, PetterssonAgneta
Language : Swedish
Author: LambertRodney A, HarveyIan, PolandFiona
Language : English
Cognitive behavioral therapy for panic disorder and comorbidity: more of the same or less of more?
Author: CraskeMichelle G, FarchioneTodd J, AllenLaura B, BarriosVelma, StoyanovaMilena, RoseRaphael
Language : English
Author: ArchJoanna J, CraskeMichelle G
Language : English
Author: HansenBjarne, VogelPatrick A, StilesTore C, GötestamK Gunnar
Language : English
Author: MarchesiCarlo, De PanfilisChiara, CantoniAlessandro, GiannelliMaria R, MagginiCarlo
Language : English
Author: KiropoulosLitza A, KleinBritt, AustinDavid W, GilsonKathryn, PierCiaran, MitchellJoanna, CiechomskiLisa
Language : English
Author: TengEllen J, BaileySara D, ChaisonAngelic D, PetersenNancy J, HamiltonJoseph D, DunnNancy Jo
Language : English
Author: CoryellWilliam, RickelsHeather
Language : English
Author: Sánchez-MecaJulio, Rosa-AlcázarAna I, Marín-MartínezFulgencio, Gómez-ConesaAntonia
Language : English
Author: ChaviraDenise A, SteinMurray B, GolinelliDaniela, SherbourneCathy D, CraskeMichelle G, SullivanGreer, BystritskyAlexander, Roy-ByrnePeter P
Language : English
Author: van ApeldoornFranske J, TimmermanMarieke E, MerschPeter Paul A, van HoutWiljo J P J, VisserSako, van DyckRichard, den BoerJohan A
Language : English
Clinician-assisted Internet-based treatment is effective for panic: A randomized controlled trial.
Author: WimsEdward, TitovNickolai, AndrewsGavin, ChoiIsabella
Language : English
Author: FreireRafael C, HallakJaime E, CrippaJosé A, NardiAntonio E
Language : English
Author: HendriksGert-Jan, KeijsersGer P J, KampmanMirjam, HoogduinCees A L, Oude VoshaarRichard C
Language : English
Author: BatelaanNeeltje M, Van BalkomAnton J L M, SteinDan J
Language : English
Author: LessardMarie-Josée, MarchandAndré, PellandMarie-Ève, BellevilleGeneviève, VadeboncoeurAlain, ChaunyJean-Marc, PoitrasJulien, DupuisGilles, FleetRichard, Foldes-BusqueGuillaume, LavoieKim L
Language : English
Author: GalloKaitlin P, ChanPriscilla T, BuzzellaBrian A, WhittonSarah W, PincusDonna B
Language : English
Author: EmmrichAngela, Beesdo-BaumKatja, GlosterAndrew T, KnappeSusanne, HöflerMichael, AroltVolker, DeckertJürgen, GerlachAlexander L, HammAlfons, KircherTilo, LangThomas, RichterJan, StröhleAndreas, ZwanzgerPeter, WittchenHans-Ulrich
Language : English
Author: VosS P F, HuibersM J H, DielsL, ArntzA
Language : English
Author: HovlandAnders, NordhusInger Hilde, SjøbøTrond, GjestadBente A, BirknesBirthe, MartinsenEgil W, TorsheimTorbjørn, PallesenStåle
Language : English
Pain adversely affects outcomes to a collaborative care intervention for anxiety in primary care.
Author: MoroneNatalia E, BelnapBea Herbeck, HeFanyin, MazumdarSati, WeinerDebra K, RollmanBruce L
Language : English
Author: Van ApeldoornFranske J, Van HoutWiljo J P J, TimmermanMarieke E, MerschPeter Paul A, den BoerJohan A
Language : English
Author: GalloKaitlin P, Cooper-VinceChristine E, HardwayChristina L, PincusDonna B, ComerJonathan S
Language : English
Author: van ApeldoornF J, StantA D, van HoutW J P J, MerschP P A, den BoerJ A
Language : English
An Internet-based guided self-help intervention for panic symptoms: randomized controlled trial.
Author: van BallegooijenWouter, RiperHeleen, KleinBritt, EbertDavid Daniel, KramerJeannet, MeulenbeekPeter, CuijpersPim
Language : English
Temporal patterns of change in panic disorder during cognitive behaviour therapy: an Indian study.
Author: ManjulaM, PrasadaraoP S D V, KumaraiahV, RaguramR
Language : English
Author: GallagherMatthew W, PayneLaura A, WhiteKamila S, ShearKatherine M, WoodsScott W, GormanJack M, BarlowDavid H
Language : English
Author: GlosterAndrew T, KlotscheJens, GerlachAlexander L, HammAlfons, StröhleAndreas, GauggelSiegfried, KircherTilo, AlpersGeorg W, DeckertJürgen, WittchenHans-Ulrich
Language : English
Author: ImaiHissei, TajikaAran, ChenPeiyao, PompoliAlessandro, GuaianaGiuseppe, CastellazziMariasole, BighelliIrene, GirlandaFrancesca, BarbuiCorrado, KoestersMarkus, CiprianiAndrea, FurukawaToshi A
Language : English
Author: SandellRolf, SvenssonMartin, NilssonThomas, JohanssonHåkan, ViborgGardar, PerrinSean
Language : English
Author: HaugThomas, NordgreenTine, ÖstLars-Göran, KvaleGerd, TangenTone, AnderssonGerhard, CarlbringPer, HeiervangEinar R, HavikOdd E
Language : English
Author: FreireRafael C, ZuglianiMorena M, GarciaRafael F, NardiAntonio E
Language : English
Author: PayneLaura A, WhiteKamila S, GallagherMatthew W, WoodsScott W, ShearM Katherine, GormanJack M, FarchioneTodd J, BarlowDavid H
Language : English
Author: ChenMu-Hong, TsaiShih-Jen
Language : English
Author: PompoliAlessandro, FurukawaToshi A, ImaiHissei, TajikaAran, EfthimiouOrestis, SalantiGeorgia
Language : English
Author: PattersonBeth, Van AmeringenMichael
Language : English
Author: RiccardiChristina J, KorteKristina J, SchmidtNorman B
Language : English
Author: ImaiHissei, TajikaAran, ChenPeiyao, PompoliAlessandro, FurukawaToshi A
Language : English
Author: BighelliIrene, CastellazziMariasole, CiprianiAndrea, GirlandaFrancesca, GuaianaGiuseppe, KoestersMarkus, TurriniGiulia, FurukawaToshi A, BarbuiCorrado
Language : English
Author: CaldirolaDaniela, AlciatiAlessandra, RivaAlice, PernaGiampaolo
Language : English
Author: ReichJames, SchatzbergAlan, DelucchiKevin
Language : English
Author: BreilmannJohanna, GirlandaFrancesca, GuaianaGiuseppe, BarbuiCorrado, CiprianiAndrea, CastellazziMariasole, BighelliIrene, DaviesSimon Jc, FurukawaToshi A, KoestersMarkus
Language : English
Author: KeefeJohn R, ChamblessDianne L, BarberJacques P, MilrodBarbara L
Language : English
Author: KolekAntonín, PraskoJan, OciskovaMarie, HolubovaMichaela, VanekJakub, GrambalAles, SlepeckyMilos
Language : English
Author: GulpersBernice, Oude VoshaarRichard, KampmanMirjam, VerheyFrans, VAN AlphenSebastiaan, HendriksGert-Jan
Language : English
Author: KeefeJohn R, ChamblessDianne L, BarberJacques P, MilrodBarbara L
Language : English
Author: MachadoSergio, TellesGeorge, MagalhaesFranklin, TeixeiraDiogo, Amatriain-FernándezSandra, BuddeHenning, ImperatoriClaudio, Murillo-RodriguezEric, MonteiroDiogo, Telles CorreiaDiogo, Sá FilhoAlberto Souza
Language : English
Author: OussiAbdellah, HamidKarim, BouvetCyrille
Language : English
Author: GuaianaGiuseppe, MeaderNicholas, BarbuiCorrado, DaviesSimon Jc, FurukawaToshi A, ImaiHissei, DiasSofia, CaldwellDeborah M, KoestersMarkus, TajikaAran, BighelliIrene, PompoliAlessandro, CiprianiAndrea, DawsonSarah, RobertsonLindsay
Language : English
This site uses cookies. Visit our privacy policy page or click the link in any footer for more information and to change your preferences.